Clarke & Sampson Blog

Preventing Sexual Abuse Allegations in Youth Organizations

Scott Jefferson | Wednesday, December 12, 2018

As terrible as it is to consider, the vulnerability of participants in youth organizations makes them a target for sexual misconduct or abuse. In addition, those same circumstances create an opportunity for false allegations of sexual misconduct, which could be just as detrimental to your organization. This is a serious liability risk, and it is important that you do all you can to protect not only the children and young adults, but also your staff, volunteers and the organization itself.

You can take several steps to ensure your organization does not have to undergo expensive and embarrassing lawsuits, including careful screening of all employees and volunteers; strictly enforced supervision guidelines; sufficient education and training; and a specific plan of action to follow when someone suspects or reports inappropriate behavior.

Screen Potential Staff Carefully

One of the most important things your organization can do to reduce the risk of sexual misconduct or harassment allegations is to take on staff and volunteers carefully. Require that all part-time and full-time staff, regardless of job description, consent in writing to a federal criminal background check. Volunteers who have contact with minors should also be subject to a background check before being allowed to mentor or conduct activities. You should also search for all potential employees and volunteers in the National Sex Offenders Public Registry, to check for any type of sex offender record. Even staff members that generally would not have contact with minors should be screened, because they still may have the opportunity to be near youth athletes.

In addition to conducting an official background check and examining the National Sex Offenders Public Registry, you should require all applicants—whether paid or volunteer—to provide a list of non-family references, complete with contact information. However, it is not enough to simply ask for this information—with every applicant, you should follow through and contact the references. Ask specific questions about the applicant’s reputation and character to evaluate whether he or she will present a risk to your organization.

Depending on the size of your organization, many people may look at one application, and the review process could go through several hands. To make the process easier and more effective, require documentation for all background and reference checks conducted. Likewise, if any applicant is allowed to skip the background or reference check process, require that a waiver be signed by the person who made the decision to exempt the applicant.

Institute Supervision Guidelines

It is important to set guidelines for employee and volunteer conduct for two reasons. First, the guidelines protect minors from ill-intentioned adults. Second, they protect employees and volunteers from potentially false allegations.

Generally, the suggestion would be to avoid one-on-one contact, but that is sometimes impractical. Whenever possible, there should be at least two adults present if it is necessary to be alone with a minor for an extended period of time.

Train and Prepare Your Staff

An important step that some organizations overlook is providing adequate education and training to allow employees and volunteers to understand the risk of sexual misconduct allegations. If you educate employees and volunteers, they are more likely to work with you to help reduce the liabilities and risks associated with dealing with youths and children.

Take the time to educate staff on the relevant policies and procedures immediately after they are hired. Be sure to emphasize that sexual misconduct training is not accusatory; rather, it is for their protection. Also, it is a good idea to retrain all staff annually as a reminder about the seriousness of the risk.

Respond Immediately to Allegations

Many organizations get into trouble not because they failed to conduct the necessary background and reference checks, but because when there was evidence of accusations or problems, they did not react quickly and appropriately.

In training sessions, stress that all staff members—including volunteers—are required to report suspicions or evidence of abuse to senior staff members. Senior staff should forward these reports immediately to the proper law enforcement officials.

To avoid further risk, take immediate action. Remove the employee or volunteer allegedly responsible from duty and do not allow him or her to supervise or come in contact with minors until the investigation is complete. This may be a difficult step, especially if it causes hardship or if there is widespread belief the staff member is innocent, but it is crucial in preventing expensive lawsuits claiming negligence.

Documentation is the key to reduced risk in allegation-response situations. Keep detailed written records of the allegations and of any interviews with the victims or the alleged abusers. Revisit your records and make sure they reflect the adequate background checks and reference checks you conducted to further document your efforts to prevent abuse situations.

The bottom line is your organization should work to avoid all circumstances that could lead to accusations of sexual misconduct or abuse, whether those claims are legitimate or false. You have a duty to protect your staff, volunteers, and the youth participants from the risks of abuse and harassment accusations. This can be challenging, but with proper guidance and careful planning you can mitigate those risks and liabilities.

Contact Us